Thinking about making the move to higher education as a teacher? It’s worth considering the tenure process, so how does tenure work in K-12 vs higher education?
Today, we’re diving into a topic that’s often misunderstood: the differences between tenure in K-12 education versus higher education. If you’re navigating the world of teaching or considering a career change, understanding these distinctions is crucial. Let’s break it down with five key differences.
Number one: Stability and Income Predictability. In K-12 education, once you achieve tenure, typically after a probationary period of several years, your job security is strong. You’re assured a stable income and a clear career path. This stability is comforting for many educators who value consistency in their professional lives.
In contrast, higher education tenure is more competitive and often involves a probationary period as well. However, tenure-track faculty in higher ed don’t have the same income predictability until they achieve tenure, which can take several years. This transition can be a significant adjustment for those accustomed to the stability of K-12.
Number two: Salary Increases and Promotion. In K-12 education, salary increases are often tied to a structured scale, with periodic raises based on years of service and sometimes additional qualifications. Promotion to higher pay grades can occur through clear criteria and timelines.
In higher education, salary increases and promotions are tied closely to the tenure process. Faculty members compile a portfolio of their work, which undergoes rigorous review by peers, department heads, deans, and sometimes university provosts and boards of regents. This comprehensive evaluation process determines both promotion and potential salary increases.
Number three: Evaluation Process. In K-12 education, evaluations typically focus on teaching performance, adherence to curriculum standards, and contributions to school community. These evaluations are often conducted by school administrators and sometimes involve peer reviews.
Conversely, the tenure evaluation process in higher education is multifaceted and involves multiple layers of assessment. It begins with peer evaluations, progresses to department and school-level reviews, and culminates in recommendations by deans and provosts before final approval by the board of regents or similar governing bodies.
Number four: Job Security and Mobility. Tenure in K-12 education provides strong job security within a specific school district or institution. While mobility between districts is possible, tenure status generally does not transfer. This can impact educators looking to relocate.
In higher education, achieving tenure offers significant job security within the university or college system. However, tenure is institution-specific, meaning a tenured professor must go through a similar process if they move to a new university. This can influence career decisions and geographic flexibility.
Number five: Cultural and Professional Implications. The culture surrounding tenure in K-12 education often emphasizes stability, community involvement, and long-term commitment to student success. In contrast, higher education tenure reflects a focus on research, publication, and academic contributions alongside teaching excellence.
Understanding these differences is crucial whether you’re a teacher aiming for tenure in K-12 or considering a move to higher education. Each path offers unique opportunities and challenges, shaping the landscape of your teaching career.
Drop a comment below with your questions or ideas for additional video.
► Stay Connected and FREEBIES * WEBSITE https://www.ethicalela.com/ * FREE WRITING WORKSHOP CURRICULUM: https://www.ethicalela.com/getting-started-with-choice-writing/ * JOIN THE OPEN WRITE: https://www.ethicalela.com/openwrite/ * FOLLOW VERSELOVE: https://www.ethicalela.com/verselove/ * INSTAGRAM /sarahjdonovan9 * FACEBOOK / sarahjdonovan9
► How to Support Ethical ELA: Buy Me a Coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/sarahjdonovan 💛PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/DrSJDonovan 😍 SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.com/@sarah.j.donovan
Clear, concise article Sarah. One that I pondered throughout my entire career. I opted to stick with K-12, despite several forays into the university level teaching…never in line for tenure as that PhD just wasn’t where my energy was. I commend you for managing that whole arena. It’s a lot of work, the world of educating be it kindergarten or u-level. We need great educators like SDonovan up and down that pipeline. I hope OSU lines you up with a big, fat raise. 🙂 Much better than a cup of coffee! LOL! Hugs, Susie
Thanks, Susie. While I can say that I’d be and am an educator in spite of the salary, salary is about dignity and worth, too. And I’ve had to navigate that line of late. HUGS.